Hands down, Finagle makes Boston's best bagels. Every variety is mixed fresh and hand-baked daily right here, so you can be sure you're eating the very freshest bagel possible. It's a Boston breakfast classic. Now you can have you favorite bagels regardless of where you live in the United States.
Click Here to order any of your favorites.
Or read below to learn more about order bagels by mail
Frequently Asked Questions
How long will it take the bagels to get from Finagle to my doorstep?
Depending on what shipping package you choose it varies; anywhere from overnight to three days.
Do you deliver to P.O. boxes?
It is FedEx's policy not to deliver perishable goods to P.O. boxes
Will the bagels be fresh?
If handled properly by FedEx and received upon delivery, the bagels will be delicious. We don't add artificial preservative to any of our bagels so express shipping is required.
Can I freeze the bagels to make them keep longer?
Yes. In fact, unless consuming all of the bagels upon delivery, it is recommended to put them in the freezer for future use. We suggest slicing, packing in plastic bags then freezing the bagels. To enjoy the bagels, let the bagel thaw for up to 2 hours or place the sliced, frozen bagel halves directly into the toaster!
Warning: Do NOT microwave bagels.
How long will the bagels stay fresh after they are delivered?
Depending on when you receive them, the bagels should stay fresh up to a few days in their plastic bags. It's recommended to freeze them for future use. Warning: Do NOT microwave bagels.
Can I get EVERY kind of bagel that Finagle serves?
No, unfortunately there are some specialty bagels and seasonal bagels that are only available in our retail stores.
What are my shipping options?
Express First Overnight - 1 Day
Express Priority Overnight - 1 Day
Express Standard Overnight - 1 Day
Express Economy - 2 Day
Express Saver - 3 Day
I just placed my order online. How will I know the order was received?
After submitting your order on our website, you should receive a confirmation email to the email address that you provided when you placed your order. Once Fedex picks up your order, a confirmation from Fedex will be sent to your email address.
What if I receive something that I am not satisfied with?
If you have any questions regarding your bagel purchase, please contact the Guest Relations Office at
guestrelations@finagleonline.com or by phone, 617-213-8428
I don't feel comfortable giving my credit card information over the Internet. How can I place a phone order?
Please call 617-213-8428 and place your order by phone.
Will sales tax be added to my order?
No. Sales tax is not required.
How long will the bagels keep in the freezer?
If handled properly, our bagels will keep in the freezer up to three months.
Order bagels online
